Is “how much?” the right question to ask about exercise for pain?

 

Exercise is widely accepted to be beneficial for health and is increasingly prescribed as treatment for many diseases and other chronic health conditions. Many studies in both humans and rodents have investigated the effectiveness of exercise as a treatment for chronic pain. Although the efficacy of exercise in rodent models of persistent pain appears to be uniformly excellent, in humans the findings are heterogeneous at best.

There are a number of factors that may explain these apparently different outcomes. For example, the heterogeneity in human studies could be related in part to the number of variables that must be considered (the type of exercise, exercise frequency, exercise intensity, type of pain, patient characteristics, etc.). Rodent studies, on the other hand, generally seek to reduce the number of variables as well as the heterogeneity of outcomes. For example, forced treadmill running is often employed to better control the exercise “dose” (distance, intensity, etc.), in contrast with the highly heterogeneous voluntary wheel running approach. While the use of forced running has some logistical benefits, it unfortunately also has serious drawbacks. For example, in the stress literature, forced exercise has long been used as a stressor2-4,22,24,29 that can produce a wide variety of undesirable effects5,6,9,14,19,23,28 including anxiety-like behavior16, elevated corticosterone levels10,13 and other physiological measures associated with chronic stress20,21.

Interestingly, while virtually all rodent studies using forced running paradigms show significantly reduced pain, they do not measure stress levels nor do they discuss the possible role of stress-induced analgesia, an innate pain-reducing response evoked by stressful or fear-inducing stimuli, as an alternative pain-reducing mechanism in their outcomes. As such, since forced exercise-induced stress could conceivably produce potent analgesia independently of beneficial exercise-induced effects, it is difficult to interpret outcomes of rodent studies employing forced running paradigms that do not rule out the involvement of stress-induced analgesia.

While forced exercise reduces heterogeneity by controlling all aspects of running behavior, voluntary wheel running increases heterogeneity by yielding control to the test subject. This is important considering that perceived control of the stressor as well as of goal-directed behavior are key factors in reducing the stress and increasing resilience 17,18

In our study, we gave rats with persistent ankle inflammation access to running wheels for a few hours per day for 3 weeks, where they could run as much or as little as they liked. We found that, as a group, the injured rats ran as much as sham rats, with similar levels of inter-individual variability in running behavior. We also found that rats with access to running wheels showed rapid and important reductions in stress measures as well as a progressive improvement in pain outcomes. Strikingly, the amount of voluntary running in each rat was unrelated to the degree of benefit achieved, a finding that bears similarities to Benjamin Greenwood’s work7,8,11 and that of others1,12,25,26 showing no relationship between voluntary running behavior in rodents and measures of stress/reward.

Taken together, our findings raise some interesting points:

  • First, there does not appear to be a set exercise threshold or “dose” that is maximally beneficial for each individual.
  • Second, voluntary exercise-induced stress reduction seems to occur earlier than the progressive benefit in pain, suggesting that reducing stress may be an important component of voluntary exercise-induced analgesia in rodents.
  • Finally, considering the important role of controllability in the perceived stressfulness of stressors,17,18 the beneficial effects of voluntary running in rats may be related to an increased sense of control over their own behavior, in contrast to forced treadmill running.

Although this line of research requires additional work to identify the physiological mechanism(s), our study clearly demonstrates that the benefits of physical exercise in rodents are much more than a simple tally of “miles covered.” In a similar vein, human studies seem to show comparable results: A recent meta-analysis of 48 randomized controlled trials on the effects of exercise on osteoarthritis pain showed that regular aerobic exercise (i.e., three times per week for 12 weeks) is most effective compared to other exercise paradigms. They found no effect of exercise intensity and no evidence to support individualized exercise programs based on patient characteristics.15 Therefore, the right question may not be “how much?” but “how often?” In other words, perhaps the benefits of exercise are maximized not by viewing it as a “more-is-better” chore, but as a fun activity to be enjoyed on a regular basis.

About Mark Pitcher

Mark Pitcher NIH Mark Pitcher is a Visiting Fellow at NIH (National Institutes of Health, U.S.A.). His research aims to identify the bio-psychosocial factors that influence inter-individual variability in chronic pain and its comorbidities. Another area of ​​research is to characterize new subpopulations of chronic pain. Through a diversified approach, Mark integrates several research techniques including behavioral pharmacology, biochemistry and epidemiology. He received his Bachelor of Psychology degree from Bishop’s University and his PhD in Neuroscience from McGill University. He has received several awards for his research and his involvement at national and international level. Recently Dr. Pitcher has worked on the development of national policies on pain research in the United States (NIH) and Canada (CIHR).

References

  1. Belke TW, Wagner JP. The reinforcing property and the rewarding aftereffect of wheel running in rats: A combination of two paradigms. Behav Processes. 2005; 68:165-172.
  1. Clement HW, Schäfer F, Ruwe C, Gemsa D, Wesemann W. Stress-induced changes of extracellular 5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid concentrations followed in the nucleus raphe dorsalis and the frontal cortex of the rat. Brain Res. 1993; 614(1-2):117-24.
  1. Das A, Rai D, Dikshit M, Palit G, Nath C. Nature of stress: differential effects on brain acetylcholinesterase activity and memory in rats. Life Sci. 2005; 77(18):2299-311.
  1. Duclos M, Martin C, Malgat M, Mazat JP, Chaouloff F, Mormède P, Letellier T. Relationships between muscle mitochondrial metabolism and stress-induced corticosterone variations in rats. Pflugers Arch. 2001; 443(2):218-26.
  1. Gavrilović L, Stojiljković V, Kasapović J, Pejić S, Todorović A, Pajović SB, Dronjak S. Forced exercise changes catecholamine synthesis in the spleen of adult rats. J Neuroimmunol. 2012; 251(1-2):1-5.
  1. Gavrilovic L, Mandusic V, Stojiljkovic V, Kasapovic J, Stojiljkovic S, Pajovic SB, Dronjak S. Effect of chronic forced running on gene expression of catecholamine biosynthetic enzymes in stellate ganglia of rats. J Biol Regul Homeost Agents. 2012; 26(3):367-77.
  1. Greenwood BN, Foley TE, Day HE, Campisi J, Hammack SH, Campeau S, Maier SF, Fleshner M. Freewheel running prevents learned helplessness/behavioral depression: Role of dorsal raphe serotonergic neurons. J Neurosci. 2003; 23:2889-2898.
  1. Greenwood BN, Foley TE, Le TV, Strong PV, Loughridge AB, Day HE, Fleshner M. Long-term voluntary wheel running is rewarding and produces plasticity in the mesolimbic reward pathway. Behav Brain Res. 2011; 217:354-362.
  1. Griesbach GS, Tio DL, Vincelli J, McArthur DL, Taylor AN. Differential effects of voluntary and forced exercise on stress responses after traumatic brain injury. J Neurotrauma. 2012; 29(7):1426-33.
  1. Griesbach GS, Tio DL, Nair S, Hovda DA. Recovery of stress response coincides with responsiveness to voluntary exercise after traumatic brain injury. J Neurotrauma. 2014; 31(7):674-82.
  1. Herrera JH, Fedynska S, Ghasem PR, Wieman T, Clark PJ, Gray N, Loetz E, Campeau S, Fleshner M, Greenwood BN. Neurochemical and behavioural indices of exercise reward are independent of exercise controllability. Eur J Neurosci. 2016; 43:1190–1202.
  1. Kanarek RB, Gerstein AV, Wildman RP, Mathes WF, D’Anci KE. Chronic running-wheel activity decreases sensitivity to morphine-induced analgesia in male and female rats. Pharmacol Biochem Behav. 1998; 61:19-27.
  1. Ke Z, Yip SP, Li L, Zheng XX, Tong KY. The effects of voluntary, involuntary, and forced exercises on brain-derived neurotrophic factor and motor function recovery: a rat brain ischemia model. PLoS One. 2011; 6(2):e16643.
  1. Kennard JA, Woodruff-Pak DS. A comparison of low- and high-impact forced exercise: effects of training paradigm on learning and memory. Physiol Behav. 2012; 106(4):423-7.
  1. Juhl C, Christensen R, Roos EM, Zhang W, Lund H. Impact of exercise type and dose on pain and disability in knee osteoarthritis: a systematic review and meta-regression analysis of randomized controlled trials. Arthritis Rheumatol. 2014; 66(3):622–636.
  1. Leasure JL, Jones M. Forced and voluntary exercise differentially affect brain and behavior. Neuroscience. 2008; 156:456–465.
  1. Maier SF, Drugan RC, Grau JW. Controllability, coping behavior, and stress-induced analgesia in the rat. Pain. 1982; 12:47-56.
  1. Maier SF. Stressor controllability and stress-induced analgesia. Ann N Y Acad Sci.1986; 467:55-72.
  1. Mancardi D, Tullio F, Crisafulli A, Rastaldo R, Folino A, Penna C, Pagliaro P. Omega 3 has a beneficial effect on ischemia/reperfusion injury, but cannot reverse the effect of stressful forced exercise. Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis. 2009; 19(1):20-6.
  1. Melo SF, Lunz W, Fontes EP, Dias CM, Carneiro MA Jr, Moura AG, Del Carlo RJ, Natali AJ. Different levels of Hsp72 in female rat myocardium in response to voluntary exercise and forced exercise. Arq Bras Cardiol. 2009; 93(5):456-62.
  1. Moraska A, Deak T, Spencer RL, Roth D, Fleshner M. Treadmill running produces both positive and negative physiological adaptations in Sprague-Dawley rats. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol. 2000; 279(4):R1321-9.
  1. Paré WP. Prior stress and susceptibility to stress ulcer. Physiol Behav. 1986; 36(6):1155-9.
  1. Rizi AA, Reisi P, Naghsh N. Effect of forced treadmill exercise and blocking of opioid receptors with naloxone on memory in male rats. Adv Biomed Res. 2016; 5:20.
  1. Selye H. Ischemic necrosis: prevention by stress. Science. 1967; 156(3779):1262-3.
  1. Smith MA, Lyle MA. Chronic exercise decreases sensitivity to mu opioids in female rats: correlation with exercise output. Pharmacol Biochem Behav. 2006; 85:12-22.
  1. Smith MA, Yancey DL. Sensitivity to the effects of opioids in rats with free access to exercise wheels: mu-opioid tolerance and physical dependence. Psychopharmacology (Berl). 2003; 168:426-434.
  1. Svensson M, Rosvall P, Boza-Serrano A, Andersson E, Lexell J, Deierborg T. Forced treadmill exercise can induce stress and increase neuronal damage in a mouse model of global cerebral ischemia. Neurobiol Stress. 2016; 5:8-18.
  1. Taché Y, Du Ruisseau P, Ducharme JR, Collu R. Pattern of adenohypophyseal hormone changes in male rats following chronic stress. Neuroendocrinology. 1978; 26(4):208-19.

Commissioning Editors: Lorimer Moseley and Neil O’Connell; Associate Editor: Adrian Traeger